NJ2018 Meeting 6-1
classics
Things to Discuss
Style Guide
- Chinese
- ?
- Korean
- ?
- English
- How to show 향명
- How to translate 순
- When to include 한자, 한글
- Term standardization process
- Lyndsey will try to check while editing the texts, then relay info, questions to others
- Distinction in content and formatting for:
- Original commentary:
- In-line translation:
- Editor's notes:
- Footnotes:
- Further Reading:
Proofreading Work
- Chinese: Jeeeun
- Korean: Jeeeun
- English: Lyndsey
- Romanization: Hae-won
Glossary Topics
- solar & lunar terms
- farming tools + fertilizers
- varieties of plants and parts of the plant
- types of land
- methods
- seed preparation
- land selection
- plowing
- planting
- weeding
- harvesting
- units of measurement
- other common words which we have standardized the translation for? (경, 종, 양, 상시, 중시, 하시, etc.) - for our own reference/style guide?
- how to divide the completion of these things?
Glossary Structure & Management
- What items can be put in a table?
- What items should be on each chapter page? Which should be on glossary page? What determines this?
- What order should we put the languages in?
- What items need multimedia? How and where to show this?
- What about a glossary template to make inclusion of info easy and to standardize the output format?
- How is glossary different from standard terms?
- Should glossary terms have their own page?
Contribution
- How should we note this?
- First, what kinds of contributions are there?
- Tables
- Guidelines
- Glossary definitions
- Multimedia
- Editor's notes
- What are the ways to show them?
- Buttons?
- Reference tags?
- Top fo the section?
- Bottom of the section?
- Parenthesis after the line?
- On a separate page like this?
- First, what kinds of contributions are there?
Feedback
Anca
- Style Guide:
- Leave sun as it is and add note with other possible translations or links for what we discussed in class about 'decade' etc.
- For terms where 향명 is given I think we can include 한자, it can be helpful for those studying the text in the future. And maybe we should show 한자 for name of places and persons/historical personalities (I remember in the preface there were some names?)
- Glossary topics:
- I think the way Lindsey selected the terms based on categories should be done for all parts. We need to re-read the text for that to be sure we include as much terms as possible.
- Other standardized terms: I think it is good to include them and give examples with how they are used in Chinese.
- Glossary Structure&Management:
- Language order: Chinese, Korean, English seems logic.
- Multimedia: for tools, plant varieties, solar/lunar terms.
- It can be a lot of work, but for terms which have additinal information, we can make them clickable so they have their own page that includes the things we found about them. I don't know much about wiki, but it seems like this would be very complex :D .
- Contribution:
- When we show our names maybe we can show it as a link to our perso al pages. Those we did at the beginning of the semester? :D
- Showing the contributor's name at the top of the section is more visible.
- Is there a way to connect everything/or the sections one person makes with their personal pages? So when we go on a person's page we can see their contributions there, click on them, and go to every section they made?
- Other suggestions:
- For those learning hanmun by studying this text in the future it would be good to make pages for certain patterns prof. Kim told us about in class and how they should be translated and how they were translated in NJ. But this is maybe something we have to make at the very end after everything else is finalized.
Today's Decisions
Chinese Text
- Just check for typos
- Key terms bolded
Korean Text
- Just fix the inaccurate translations
- Do not need to worry too much about formatting or consistency
- Key terms bolded
English Text
- Lunar week, It is commonly called ___ / with clear editor's notes
- Do not include any 한자, 한글
- Use revised romanization (but include MR in glossary)
- Key terms bolded
Commentary, Editor's Notes, Etc.
- Original commentary: Keep formatting as it is for now
- Translator added words in text for clarification: parenthesis
- Editor's notes: Modified reference tag, located under each language
- Further Reading: Journal articles or texts about the particular chapter
- References: Citations for editor's notes
Glossary
Themes
Group glossary terms by themes with each theme having its own page.
- Plant varieties
- Farming tools
- Land types
- Measurements
- Calendar terms
- Methods
Glossary Info
- Title in English or RR
- Hanja
- Hangeul
- RR
- MR
- Common name hanja
- Common name hangeul
- Common name RR
- Common name MR
- Alternate English terms
- (Pinyin)
- Definition/explanation
- Multimedia
- Further reading
- Where it appears in 농사직설 (sample text, link to chapter)
Contributions
- Overall responsibilities: Noted on Editor's notes page
- Contributor's template: Used in the case that you contributed to some other part not outlined below
Overview of Final Project Responsibilies
Anca
- Glossary (languages, explanation, multimedia, tables if appropriate)
- Plant varieties
- Farming tools
Changsup
- Glossary (languages, explanation, multimedia, tables if appropriate)
- Methods (selecting soil, preparing soil, preparing seeds, sowing, weeding, harvesting)
- Units of measurement
Evelyn
- Glossary (languages, explanation, multimedia, tables if appropriate)
- Calendar (solar, lunar calendar terms)
- Land types
Hae-won
- Wiki Management
- Make basic glossary pages
- Make glossary template
- Overall further reading page
- Romanization proofreading
Jeeeun
- Chinese & Korean Text Editing
- Record style notes
- Bold possible terms
Lyndsey
- English Text Editing
- Record style notes
- Bold possible terms
Timeline for Final Project
- By Mon., June 4
- Templates made by Hae-won
- Check-up meeting (Weds., June 6, 3pm)
- Text editing should be completed
- Glossary term list should be completed
- Final review (Weds. June 13, ??_
- Glossary should be completed (explanations, multimedia, etc.)
