Korea’s Place in Global History
This paper analyzes major themes and central arguments presented in the five representative textbooks of world history and East Asia in the English-speaking world.[1] The purpose of this paper is to offer a brief introduction to Korean history as told by Anglo-European historians. Korean history, as presented in these works, forms an integral part of world history, the grand narrative of human societies constructed by generations of scholars in the Anglo-European academe. While making efforts to place Korean in the context of world history, the main focus of this paper should be on Korean history in these works. Any attempt to separate Korean history out from the larger contexts of world history by heeding only the parts related to Korea might risk decontextualizing it. In lieu of providing a mere summary of these works, I have tried to critically assess these textbooks: that is, to illuminate their professed purposes as well as hidden agendas.
목차
- 1 Part I: Early Korea
- 2 Part II: Goryeo Korea (935-1392)
- 2.1 Early Goryeo Government (935-1170)
- 2.2 The Changing International Context (943-1146)
- 2.3 Goryeo Society and Culture
- 2.4 Family and Kinship
- 2.5 Buddhism and Confucianism
- 2.6 Military Rule and Choe Family Dominance
- 2.7 The Mongol Invasions (1170-1259)
- 2.8 Goryeo under Mongol Domination (1260-1351)
- 3 Part III: Joseon Korea (1392-1800)
- 3.1 Yi Seonggye’s Rise to Power
- 3.2 Kings and Yangban: Confucian Officials
- 3.3 Dynastic Decline and the Japanese Invasion
- 3.4 Relations with the Manchus
- 3.5 Internal Politics in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries
- 3.6 Economic Growth and the Decline of Slavery
- 3.7 Cultural Developments
- 3.8 Northern Learning:
- 3.9 Christianity and Western Learning
- 3.10 The Family and Women in the Confucian Age
- 4 Part IV. Modern Korea, since the mid-19th century
- 5 References
Part I: Early Korea
North: Goguryeo, Buyeo, etc.
1. The central themes of early Korean history |
|
2. Written Sources |
|
3. Nationalism in Korean History |
|
4. The Multiple Origins of the Korean People |
|
5. Archaeology |
|
6. Korean Nativism v. Chinese tradition. |
|
7. The Four Han Commanderies and state-making in early Korea |
|
8. Chinese invasions |
|
9. Goguryeo’s rise |
|
10. The Making of the Three Kingdoms |
|
11. Weapons and Warfare |
|
The South: The Three Han (Samhan)
1. The Samhan States |
|
2. The Samhan states, the population of |
|
3. Chinese Sources on Samhan |
|
4. Samhan Culture |
|
5. Samhan Culture |
|
6. Korea-Japan relations |
|
The Three Kingdoms: Goguryeo, Baekje, Silla (313-668)
1. The Rise of the Territorial States |
|
2. The Leadership of the Three Kingdoms |
|
3. The Tombs of the Three Kingdoms |
|
4. Early Korea, the shamanistic traditions of |
|
5. Shamanism |
|
6. Buyeo, the religion of |
|
7. Mahan, the religious practices of |
|
8. The Three Kingdoms, the Buddhism of |
|
9. The Rise of Goguryeo |
|
10. Goguryeo’s conflict with Xianbei |
|
11. King Gwanggaeto, the territorial expansion of |
|
12. King Gwangaeto’s relations with Xianbei |
|
13. King Gwanggaeto’s Stele |
|
14. Goguryeo influence on Japan |
|
15. Goguryeo tomb murals |
|
16. Goguryeo tomb murals |
|
17. Goguryeo tomb murals |
|
18. Goguryeo tomb murals |
|
19. Goguryeo tomb murals |
|
20. Baekje and Silla |
|
21. Baekje, the origins of |
|
22. Baekje, the territorial expansion of |
|
23. Baekje, the bureaucracy of |
|
24. Baekje, relations with Gogyryeo and Silla |
|
25. Baekje, the state-making of |
|
26. Silla’s Rise |
|
27. Baekje, the population of |
|
28. Silla, the state-making of |
|
29. Silla, the leadership of |
|
30. Silla’s contact with China |
|
31. Gaya’s Rise |
|
32. Gaya’s annexation into Silla |
|
Development of Complex Societies in Korea, Vietnam, and Japan (TE282)
1. NEW KINGDOMS IN EAST ASIA under Tang influence |
|
2. Sui attacks on Goguryeo |
|
3. Yeon Gaesomun |
|
4. Sino-Korean Relations during the Three Kingdoms Period |
|
5. Tang attacks on Goguryeo |
|
6. Silla, Tang alliance |
|
7. Silla and Tang’s destruction of Baekje |
|
8. Tang installing Five Military Commands in Baekje |
|
9. Goguryeo, the fall of |
|
10. Silla’s victory |
|
11. Silla driving out Tang forces |
|
12. Silla’s unification |
|
13. Silla-Tang Relations |
|
14. Silla’s distinction from Tang |
|
United Silla (668-892)
1. Unified Silla, state-making |
|
2. Bureaucratic specialization |
|
3. Silla’s Administration
|
|
4. By 680 the government had established five small capitals in addition to the main one at Gyeongju to spread Silla culture throughout the conquered territories. (EA 106) | |
5. Political Unrest |
|
6. Silla, the foreign relations of |
|
7. Silla, the border defence of |
|
8. Silla, the maritime trade of |
|
9. Silla, the art of |
|
10. Silla, the fall of |
|
11. The later Three Kingdoms |
|
12. Silla, the aristocracy of |
|
13. Silla, the leadership of |
|
14. Silla, the nobility of |
|
15. Silla, the aristocratic culture of |
|
16. Silla, the hwarang of |
|
17. Silla, the social strata of |
|
18. Silla, the slavery of |
|
19. Silla, the kinship organizations of |
|
20. The Three Kingdoms, the spread of Chinese culture during |
|
21. Silla-Tang relations |
|
22. Unified Silla, the Buddhism of |
|
23. Unified Silla, the Seon Buddhism of |
|
Balhae (698-926)
1. Balhae and Goguryeo |
|
2. Balhae, the founder of |
|
3. Balhae, the territories of |
|
4. Balhae, the identify of |
|
5. Malgal, the ethnicity of |
|
6. Balhae, the capital of |
|
7. Balhae, the diplomatic relations of |
|
8. Multi-ethnicity of Manchuria |
|
Part II: Goryeo Korea (935-1392)
As to the Silla-Goryeo transition, the authors tend to emphasize social and cultural continuities rather than changes. In their views, the Goryeo political system was at best a limited centralized rule. 1) The founder Wang Geon (877-943; r. 918-943) consolidated his rule through marital alliance with local strongmen. 2) Gwangjong’s (925-975; r. 949-975) attempts to increase centralized control failed to weaken the hereditary aristocracy. 3) The government introduced a prebend system (begun in 976 and continued till 1076), the grants of tax-collection rights on a portion of land given to former magistrates and military officers. To place Goryeo in the global context, the authors highlight the following points: (1) Its relative independence from China in a post-Tang world beset by powerful non-Chinese neighbors; (2) the decline of commercial economy with an increasing portion of the unfree population in the hands of aristocrats and local magnates or enslaved directly by the government; (3) the failed efforts of the early reigns to strengthen central control due to the strong aristocracy propped by a system of land grants (prebends); (4) the continued influence of Buddhism; (5) the dominance of military strongmen in the government; (6) the inferiority of its military power to the much larger empires to their north, especially during the period of Mongol domination; (7) the post-1020s rise of an oligarchy of aristocratic clans with a large amount of privatized land grants and a large number of slaves; (8) the loss of direct land access to China due to the nomadic empires to the north and the vitalization of the sea routes and maritime trade; (9) the spread of books due to the development of printing and the spread of Buddhism and Confucianism. (EA112)
Early Goryeo Government (935-1170)
1. Goryeo, the Founder of |
|
2. Goryeo, Gwangjong |
|
3. Goryeo, the Preben System of |
|
4. Goryeo, Limits to centralization |
|
5. Goryeo, Economic backwardness |
|
6. Factional Struggle |
|
7. Civil Service Examinations |
|
8. The Rise of the Prominent Families |
|
9. Dynastic Crisis |
|
10. Military Coup |
|
The Changing International Context (943-1146)
1. Goreyo and the nomadic empires |
|
2. Goryeo and Khitan Liao |
|
3. Goryeo and Jurchen Jin
|
|
4. Myocheong (? - 1135), a Buddhist monk, insisted on an independent and assertive foreign policy in opposition tributary subservience preferred by King Injo’s Confucian advisers, headed by the Confucian scholar historian Kim Busik (1075-1151). Myocheong was removed by his enemies, and his push for war with the Jurchens was aborted, and close to a century of peace with Jin was preserved (EA172). |
Goryeo Society and Culture
1. Goryeo, the maritime trade of |
|
2. Goryeo, the art and literature of |
|
3. Goryeo, the social classes of |
|
4. Goryeo slaves |
|
Family and Kinship
1. Goryeo family |
|
2. Goryeo family, the characteristics of |
|
Buddhism and Confucianism
1. Goryeo Buddhism |
|
2. Goryeo Geomancy |
|
3. Seon Buddhism |
|
4. Goryeo Neo-Confucianism |
|
5. Goryeo Printing Culture |
|
6. Tripitaka Koreana
|
|
7. The art of papermaking slowly spread to the rest of the world. First, it moved east to Korea and Japan. Then, it spread westward to the Arab world in the 700s, and from there to Europe. (WI 203) | |
8. Movable type |
|
9. History-writing |
|
Military Rule and Choe Family Dominance
1. Military Coup |
|
2. Social disorder under Military rule |
|
3. Choe Family Dictatorship |
|
4. Political turmoil |
|
The Mongol Invasions (1170-1259)
1. Mongol Rule |
|
2. Khitans and Mongols |
|
3. Mongol Invasion |
|
4. Popular Suffering |
|
Goryeo under Mongol Domination (1260-1351)
1. Marital Alliance |
|
2. Mongol Invasion of Japan |
|
3. Mongol Military Control |
|
4. Mongol Invasion of Japan |
|
5. Mongols’ abuse of Goryeo Kings |
|
6. Cultural Encounters |
|
7. Goryeo under Mongol Rule |
|
8. Gunpowder |
|
9. Mongol intervention on Goryeo Slavery and close-kin marriage |
|
10. Goryeo Assimilation to Mongol Culture |
|
11. Foreigners in Goryeo |
|
12. King Gongmin’s Thwarted Reform |
|
13. Nahachu’s Invasion
|
|
14. With the decline of Mongol rule, the new breed of Goryeo scholars sought to transform Korea into a morally perfect Confucian society. Yi Jehyeon (1287-1367) who had been traveling back and forth from Bejing for several decades promoted Zhu Xi’s thought. (EA179-180) | |
15. King Gongmin’s Confucian Reform |
|
Part III: Joseon Korea (1392-1800)
The Joseon Dynasty went through the four centuries of gradual “Confucianization,” through which Korean society shed its indigenous culture and became more like China. The non-patrilineal and comparatively gender-equitable Goreyo family system was transformed into the patriarchal and patrilineal ancestor-worshipping Confucian family system during the mi-Joseon period. The hereditary yangban who checked on the royal authority were often caught up in factional struggle. Despite internal struggles and foreign invasions, the Joseon dynasty lasted close to six hundred years, a remarkable longevity for a pre-modern state. (EA 247; WI 347).
Yi Seonggye’s Rise to Power
1. Dynastic Transition |
|
2. Continuance of the ruling elite |
|
3. King Taejong built a new capital at Hanyang (Seoul), strengthened the armed forces, confiscated Buddhist temple and monastery property, and created a sound fiscal base for the state. (EA 248) | |
4. Sejong’s state-making |
|
5. Sejong’s Cultural Projects |
|
6. Sejo’s reign |
|
Kings and Yangban: Confucian Officials
1. Contradictory trends in Joseon Politics |
|
2. Centralization |
|
3. Social reproduction of the hereditary yangban class |
|
4. Anti-Buddhist campaign |
|
5. Confucian fundamentalism |
|
6. Limits to royal power |
|
7. Royal constraint on the yangban class |
|
8. Joseon Neo-Confucianism |
|
9. The yangban stratum remained powerful throughout the dynasty and even grew in size; the yangban separated into two groups |
|
10. Middle People (jungin) |
|
Dynastic Decline and the Japanese Invasion
1. Dynastic Decline |
|
2. Military unpreparedness |
|
3. Factional Struggle |
|
4. Military Unpreparedness |
|
5. The Imjin War |
|
6. Yi Sunsin’s naval forces |
|
7. Hideyoshi’s Second Invasion |
|
8. Resuming Trade with Japan |
|
Relations with the Manchus
1. The rise of the Manchus |
|
2. Gwanghaegun’s Political Struggle |
|
3. Manchu Invasion of Joseon
|
|
4. Because Joseon proved a nonthreatening vassal, she could safely be allowed to remain autonomous. (EA 255) |
Internal Politics in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries
1. Military Reform |
|
2. Factional struggle |
|
3. Yeongjo’s Coalition Cabinet |
|
4. Prince Regent Sado’s Death |
|
5. Jeongjo’s rule |
|
Economic Growth and the Decline of Slavery
1. Limited Commerce |
|
2. National Defense |
|
3. Fiscal Problems |
|
4. Tribute Tax Quotas |
|
5. Recruiting slaves for military service |
|
6. Circulation of Coins |
|
7. Demographics
|
|
8. Average production per acre in Korea as late as 1900 was about the same as in China in 1400 (15 bushels), and about two-thirds of p roduction in Japan and China around 1880.” (EA 257) | |
9. Commerce Activity |
|
10. Coin mintage |
|
11. Private Merchants |
|
12. Joseon slavery |
|
13. The decline of slavery |
|
14. From slaves to tenant farmers |
|
Cultural Developments
1. Rise of New Ideas |
|
2. Rise of New Literature
|
|
3. Popular oral literature also flourished. Rural dances and local masked plays were often biting in the satire. Pasori was an oral song tradition that became popular in the countryside in the eighteenth century. (EA 260) |
Northern Learning:
1. The intellectually rigid Confucianism of early Joseon changed in the eighteenth century with the introduction of new ideas from Qing China. The so-called Northern Learning Group, mostly from the minority Southerner or Northerner factions, sought to adopt new ideas from the Qing dynasty for economic prosperity and material well-being. (EA 260) | |
2. Escape from Sino-centrism |
|
3. Limits of Northern Learning |
|
Christianity and Western Learning
1. Adoption of Western Ideas |
|
2. Critique of Christianity |
|
3. Christian Converts |
|
4. Persecution of Converts |
|
5. King Jeongjo executed the first Christian missionary the Chinese Zhou Wenmo in 1794, and purged the sympathetic Southerners. (EA 261) |
The Family and Women in the Confucian Age
1. The Confucian Transformation of Joseon |
|
2. Genealogy |
|
3. The Spread of Confucian Practices |
|
4. Primogeniture |
|
5. Women in Confucian Society |
|
6. Women and Popular religions |
|
Part IV. Modern Korea, since the mid-19th century
The End of the Joseon Dynasty
1. Korean in the middle |
|
2. Unequal Treaties |
|
3. Japanese imperial aims |
|
4. Sino-Japanese War
|
|
5. Japanese Racism. In the 1890s, Japanese newspapers portrayed Chinese and Korean peoples as dirty, backward, stupid, and cowardly. Some even argued that the Japanese people were more akin to the "Aryans" than to the " Mongolians." (TE 769) | |
6. Western Powers’ pressure on Japan |
|
7. Russo-Japanese War |
|
Japanese Colonial Rule, 1910s-1930s
1. Japanese Colonization of Korea |
|
2. Harsh Colonial Rule |
|
3. Japanese Occupation of Korea |
|
4. Japanese Expansion in East Asia |
|
5. Western Missionaries |
|
6. Western Indifference to Japanese brutality |
|
7. The Non-Violent March First Movement |
|
8. Comfort Women |
|
The Korean War 1950-1953
1. The Creation of the Two Koreas |
|
2. Outbreak of the Korean War |
|
3. The North Korean Invasion |
|
4. UN Intervention |
|
5. PRC intervention |
|
6. The Progress of the Korean War |
|
7. Stalemate and Armistice |
|
Post-War Construction since 1953
1. US-sponsored rehabilitation |
|
2. Post-war Reconstruction |
|
3. North Korea |
|
4. South Korea |
|
References
- ↑ The list of the textbooks analyzed in this paper is as follows:
WI: Beck, Roger B., et al. World History: Patterns of Interaction. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company, 2012. ISBN 9780547491127
WH: Ellis, E. G. and Esler, A. (Prentice Hall) World History. Pearson Education, 2009. ISBN 9780133720488
TE: Bentley, J. H., et al. Traditions and Encounters: A Global Perspective on the Past. Volume I and II. McGraw-Hili Education, 2015. ISBN 9780077504908, ISBN 9780077504915
EP: Bulliet, R.W., et al. The Earth and Its Peoples: A Global History, 6th Edition. Volume I and II. Cengage Learning, 2014. ISBN 9781285436913, ISBN 9781285436968
EA: Ebrey, Patricia B. and Walthall, Anne. East Asia: A Cultural, Social, and Political History. Wadsworth Publishing, 2013. ISBN 9781133606475
- TE2015-1.png
Bentley, J. H., et al. Traditions & Encounters Vol.1 From the Beginning to 1500. 2015
ISBN 9780077504908 - TE2015-2.png
Bentley, J. H., et al. Traditions & Encounters Vol.2 from 1500 to the Present. 2015
ISBN 9780077504915 - EP2014-2.jpg
Bulliet, R.W., et al. The Earth and Its Peoples: A Global History Vol II. 2014
ISBN 9781285436968