"(2017Translation) 蝴蝶夢"의 두 판 사이의 차이

2017년 7월 6일 (목) 17:35 판

Primary Document
Title
English	Butterfly dream
Chinese	蝴蝶夢(Hudie meng)
Korean(RR)	호접몽
Document Details
Genre
Type
Author(s)	Zhuangzi 莊子
Year
Key Concepts
Translation Info
Translator(s)	Participants of 2017 Summer Hanmun Workshop (Intermediate Training Group)
Editor(s)
Year	2017

Original Script

Translation

Student 1 : Sanghoon Na

Formerly, Zhuang Zhou had a dream of becoming a butterfly, a happily fluttering^[1] butterfly talking to himself "This is what I want!" He did not know that it was he. Suddenly he awoke, and then clearly realized^[2] it was he. He did not know whether it was he dreaming of becoming a butterfly, or it was a butterfly dreaming of becoming him. [But] Between Zhou and a butterfly, there must be a distinction! This is called the "transitory character of things."^{[3] [4]}。

Footnotes

1. ↑ 栩栩然 [註 165] 허허연(栩栩然) : 기뻐하는 모양. 세조실록 45권
2. ↑ 蘧蘧然 [註 166] 거거연(籧籧然) : 스스로 깨닫는 모양. 세조실록 45권
3. ↑ 物化 물화(物化): the transitory character of things (Charles Muller)
4. ↑ 物化 물화(物化): the Transformation of Things (James Legge)

Student 2 : (Younès M'Ghari)

Once, Zhuang Zhou dreamt of being a butterfly, a fluttering butterfly. He himself was feeling very happy and could go wherever he wanted to. He did not know he was Zhou. He suddenly woke up and then was clearly Zhou. He did not know either it was Zhou dreaming of being a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming of being Zhou. If it is about Zhou and a butterfly, there should be a distinction. This is called the transformation into things.

Student 3 : (Write your name)

Student 4 : (Write your name)

Once Zhuangzi dreamt of being a butterfly, and like a butterfly, was flutteringly happy and carefree. [He] did not know he was Zhuangzi.

Suddenly he awoke, apparently Zhuangzi.

[He] did not know if he was Zhuangzi dreaming [of] being a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming [of] being Zhuangzi.

If [there is] a Zhuangzi and a butterfly, then there must be a distinction. This is called becoming a thing.

Student 5 : (Jae Yong Chang)

There was a man in the state of Chu who was selling a shield and a spear. (He was) proudly saying that my shield was so strong that nothing made it damaged. Saying again, my spear was also so sharp on anything that it’s impossible to be damaged. A person asked if you were to take your spear to strike your shield, what would it happen? Then he couldn’t be answered. Generally speaking, a shield that cannot be damaged and a spear that cannot be damaged, it cannot be in the same world and existed.

Student 6 : (Write your name)

Student 7 : (Alexandre Le Marchand)

A long time ago Zhuang Zhu dreamed that he was a butterfly, flirting around as a butterfly and enjoyed this feeling. He didn’t know he was Zhu. He suddenly woken up and realize he is Zhu. He wasn’t able to know if it was himself who dreaming being a butterfly or if it was a butterfly dreaming of being him. Zhu and the butterfly, it needed to be split. This is what we call the mutation of things.

Student 8 : (Write your name)

Student 9 : (Write your name)

Student 10 : (Write your name)

Student 11 : (Write your name)

Student 12 : (Write your name)

Student 13 : Ra YeonJae

Once, ZhuangZhou dreamt of becoming a butterfly, a happily fluttering butterfly. He realized that it was exactly what he want! It did not know it was Zhou. Suddenly he woke up and it was clearly came across his mind that he was Zhou. He did not distinguish Zhou dreamt of becoming a butterfly or butterfly dreamd of becoming Zhou. If there are Zhou and butterfly, then there should be distinction between them. It is referred to as the becoming of things.

Student 14 : (Write your name)